What effect does CXL have after 10 years?

What effect does CXL have after 10 years? This August, ELZA doctor and researcher, Emilio Torres-Netto MD was interviewed by TouchOphthalmology on a recent congress presentation he gave on 10-year cross-linking follow-up data collated from two treatment centers in Zurich, and was asked about what the research group found.

 

TRANSCRIPT:

What is the rationale for corneal cross-linking in progressive keratoconus?

The rationale is basically halting the disease. So unlike other therapies that have a primary purpose of improving the visual performance, corneal cross-linking (CXL) brought for the first time the possibility of halting the natural progression of keratoconus. It stiffens the cornea and we know that the cornea is weakened in keratoconus and the biomechanics are changed, so by stiffening the cornea, it can potentially halt the progression over time.

Before your study, how much long-term data on the use of corneal cross-linking were available?

Not that much actually, very limited information was available for us on long-term follow-up. There are now more than 500 papers in PubMed about cross-linking since it was established in 2002/3… but in the long-term, actually, there isn’t that much. We do have the Sienna study with quite a long follow-up and also we have a Dresden follow-up with 10 years of data, with similar results. The overall result is quite similar to ours, so they had in Dresden their Kmax (i.e. the maximum keratometry) reducing by around 0.1 logMAR; more or less was what we found, and the main difference is that our series shows a bit more stability of refractive outcomes, so both in terms of spherical equivalent and also astigmatism. But our findings from patients in Zurich and the findings from patients in Dresden (published previously) agree a lot between them. We decided to evaluate this data because of course, it can bring a greater understanding: more information about what can happen in the long term, and a better understanding of how we could potentially manage the patients better.

 

 

What were the outcomes of your study of 10-year outcomes of corneal cross-linking for progressive keratoconus?

The data that we had were collected from surgeries between 2004 and 2019. The surgeries were performed at IROC and the ELZA institute, both in Switzerland. We had more than 400 surgeries, but to evaluate the long term, after 10 years, you can imagine we could not reach all of those patients again, some of them did not have the follow-up completed so we ended up analyzing 50 eyes! And what we saw, was that, as expected, cross-linking could stabilize keratoconus progression. We had around 50 of the patients stable visual acuity, and this was more or less one-line stability and 36 percent actually had improvement of more than one line after 10 years. This really surprised us, because that was not initially the idea to improve vision, the idea is to stabilize it. But we could see that many patients had also an improvement in visual acuity from baseline levels. So 10 years after cross thinking, we saw a decrease in keratometry (the Kmax) of around 1.5 diopters in 10 years. That’s quite a lot considering that there is a long time interval but I would say what we were most interested in was understanding how visual acuity in the long term would change. So this is a challenge. We have to answer patients who ask: “Can my visual acuity can stay over a long period?”. We see that 50 percent stay stable. But we would like to see if there was anything that we could have predicted, such as worsening of visual acuity for example. We looked for any risk factor of changing visual acuity, but we could not find any relationship between VA loss and age or also with any Scheimpflug measurements like game maximum keratometry or any other parameters… but we did see some correlations with pre-operative visual acuity. So in other words, the most severe visual worsening that we saw was in those eyes with the best pre-operative visual acuity. There are other studies saying this as well; this confirms that good pre-operative visual activity can be a risk factor for visual acuity changes so that was maybe what we find most interesting.

What adverse effects were seen and how many repeat procedures were needed?

Of course, we had some failures of the treatment and we could not evaluate all patients treated thanks to loss to follow-up, but we did evaluate treatment failure which is a long-term complication. So from 42 eyes that had not had other refractive procedures, we saw that two eyes required re-cross-linking (so a second procedure). One of them was 32 and the other 19 years old, and then another eye needed a keratoplasty (DALK) and that patient was also young at the time of course (I think he was 25 years old). Another three eyes progress (an increase in Kmax) in the overall period, so we could say that, overall, cross-linking had stopped the progression of keratoconus in around 85 percent of patients after 10 years. That was our main finding. 

What will be the impact of these findings on clinical practice?

Once we understand better the outcomes of CXL after 10 years, we are better able to improve our treatments. One of the curiosities we found was that the two youngest patients in our case series (both of them were nine years old on the day of the surgery). They remained stable after 10 years of cross-linking. So such small observations are also very valid because there is a discussion about whether the collagen turnover from the cornea means that the cross-linking effect might be lost over the long term, and this might mean that younger age has a negative impact on post-cross-linking outcomes. But observing that two 9-year-old children (at the time of treatment) were still stable 10 years after cross-linking, gives us some very important insight on the long-term stability of corneal cross-linking. 

The ELZA Institute

EN | DE

Augeninstitut ELZA
4.7
Based on 101 reviews
powered by Google
Serena Fazio
Serena Fazio
11:15 06 Mar 22
I have been to the ELZA clinic to have surgery for my miopy, as my eyes were rejecting the contacts and I was tired of... wearing glasses. From the first preliminary visit, to the actual surgery and post-surgery care Dr. Hafezi and all his collaborators have been extremely professional, considerate and helpful. All the steps of the (very short!) surgery were thoroughly explained to me in order to be as calm as possible, together with the medication plan and precautions to be aware of so that my eyes could heal in the best way possible. By following their exact instructions, the healing process has been very successful and smooth, and after about one week I was able to see perfectly. I absolutely recommend this team and their expertise!read more
Robin A
Robin A
11:43 16 Feb 22
Top experts and professional team. Highly recommended
Thunder Shiviah
Thunder Shiviah
14:05 23 Nov 21
After some research on local options I decided to go with ELZA since it stood out as the best. The operation and the... post-operation recovery went extremely smooth (something I was worried about with PRK). Now my vision is much better than I had hoped and I have no side effects such as dry eye or night vision problems. Thank you!read more
Squitieri Elias
Squitieri Elias
12:43 08 Sep 21
Die Behandlungen waren bei mir erfolgreich, alle waren sehr nett und haben mein Leben vereinfacht.Danke
Eliane Bossart
Eliane Bossart
13:01 05 Sep 21
Vor einem Jahr war ich einer ganz verzweifelten Situation und total im Stich gelassen. Meine Augen wurden aufgrund... eines ausgeprägten Kerakotonus immer schlechter, ich hatte Angst und war alleine mit meinen Problemen. Zudem vertrug ich die Kontaktlinsen nur noch ganz schlecht und hatte jeden Tag Schmerzen.Professor Hafezi hat mir mit zwei Operationen wieder das auf Grund der Situation mögliche an Lebensqualität zurückgebracht. Es war ein starpaziöses Jahr mit vielen Entbehrungen aber es hat sich gelohnt! Herzlichen Dank fuer die Unterstützung.read more
Gabriela Meyer
Gabriela Meyer
18:32 22 Aug 21
Ich wurde von meiner Optikerin auf Prof. Dr. Dr. Hafezi aufmerksam gemacht. Es war mir vorher nicht bewusst, dass meine... Augenkrankheit (Keratokonus) operativ mittels Cross Linking behandelt und so gestoppt werden kann. Die Beratung und Behandlung war sehr kompetent und ich fühlte mich jederzeit wohl. Die Operation verlief gut und das Ergebnis ist einwandfrei.read more
Naomi
Naomi
11:38 11 Aug 21
Ich bin sehr glücklich, dass ich das Elza Institute gefunden habe. Ich wurde von anderen Augenärzten abgewiesen, da... meine Augen zu kompliziert/schwierig zu behandeln waren. Prof. Dr. Dr. Hafezi konnte mir jedoch helfen und ich bin sehr glücklich und zufrieden mit dem Resultat. Vielen Dank!read more
Till B
Till B
08:30 19 Jul 21
Ich habe eine überaus kompetente Beratung und Behandlung erlebt. Die gesamte Betreuung war sehr freundlich und... professionell. Herzlichen Dank!read more
Thomas S.
Thomas S.
09:37 07 Jul 21
My left eye had to be operated on because of a cataract. As I had an Artiflex lens implanted a few years ago, it had to... be removed first before a modern lens could be implanted to correct the cataract. Prof. Hafezi treated me in an very competent and friendly manner. I am very happy with the result.read more
Selma A. Rahim
Selma A. Rahim
19:45 02 Jul 21
Dr. Hafezi.. the KING OF CXL🤴
Gianluca Ricci
Gianluca Ricci
12:46 10 Apr 21
Great team and service!
rehaneyecare
rehaneyecare
05:36 08 Apr 21
Excellent surgeon
Steven H.A
Steven H.A
16:13 11 Jan 21
Prof. F. Hafezi s expertise is enormous and he has a very pleasant and calm nature which gives the patient... security.Thank youread more
Online Commande
Online Commande
09:19 05 Dec 20
Totally creepy, very arrogant Prof.He just want your money.It may explain, why this Prof. is not in the center of the... city of Zürich and why he has been thrown away from University of Geneva.read more
Elena Churilova
Elena Churilova
10:06 17 Nov 20
At the moment, 3 months have passed since the moment I made laser vision correction in this clinic. and I can say that... I am happy that I chose this particular clinic and Prof. F. Hafezi. The entire staff of the clinic is very friendly, treats patients with sympathy and patience if they are nervous before surgery (my big gratitude to Aida Alili for all support and patience). The doctor Hafezi and other doctors of the clinic are very professional and ready to explain to you as many times as you need. I can only recommend!read more
Next Reviews
js_loader
Augeninstitut ELZA
4.7
Based on 101 reviews
powered by Google
js_loader